-
Product type:
Analytical Document -
Authors:
-
Date:
03 July 2005 -
With financial support from:
Revision of privatisation in Ukraine: a cost-benefit analysis
Since the beginning of 2005, a controversial discussion on revaluation or even revision of recent privatisation deals has created substantial uncertainty of property rights in Ukraine’s economy. As an immediate result, the growth of investment activities went down significantly. In this way, and independently of whether or not revaluation or reprivatization is justified, the form of this discussion has already had a significantly negative impact on Ukraine’s macroeconomic performance. This is even more dramatic since a lower increase of investment activities at present also means lower growth of income in the future.
Against this background, our paper discusses how policy makers should continue with this process. We start by looking at two cases of international experiences where privatisation has been reviewed in the 1990s, the restitution in Poland and the revaluation of privatised utilities in the United Kingdom. The comparison demonstrates that privatisation revision causes neglectable costs only if it is conducted in a transparent and predictable way under stable political conditions and if it is limited to a revaluation without that effective changes in property rights are envisaged. As this cannot be guaranteed in the Ukrainian situation, we argue that costs of a revision of privatisation will be significant and must be compared to expected benefits of this measure.
IER Project
German Economic Team in Ukraine (GET)The project aims to develop economic policy recommendations for Ukraine based on rigorous analysis, contemporary economic theory and international best practices to support well-informed policy decisions and help identify priorities for economic development