-
Product type:
Analytical Document -
Authors:
-
Date:
06 December 2003 -
With financial support from:
Multi-Utilities: panacea or barrier to competition?
The present study discusses the question whether horizontal integration of different utility providers into one joint holding can be seen as a panacea for solving their substantial problems, or whether it even deteriorates their perspective for competition-oriented development in the future. Our conclusions are as follows:
- Merging e.g. suppliers of central heating, electricity, gas and water into one single holding will make it easier for the holding to reduce the scope for interfuel competition in e.g. heating and hot water, the only type of competition that so far prevails on Ukraine’s utility markets.
- Insufficient and inappropriate regulatory policy remains to be the main obstacle for development of competition. Against this background, merging the four monopolists bears the substantial risk of creating a strong, non-transparent formation of vested and not necessarily competition-oriented interests, which might prove to be very difficult to overrule in the future when further advances towards competition are intended.
- At the same time, no significant economic gains are expected from such a merger. While problems of mutual indebtedness of the four utilities could be solved and payment discipline might be improved, the potential for significant efficiency gains is rather limited.
Thus, joint Multi Utility holdings are unlikely to be a panacea for solving the substantial problems of utility provision in Ukraine. Instead, it limits the already low level of currently existing competition and makes it more difficult to advance towards more sophisticated modes of competition in the future. Finally, even if the merger allows realizing some moderate economic benefits, this only amounts to ease present problems of Kyiv’s utilities while the real cause underlying the poor performance – weak regulation – is not solved and might than be even more difficult to be solved in the future.
IER Project
German Economic Team in Ukraine (GET)The project aims to develop economic policy recommendations for Ukraine based on rigorous analysis, contemporary economic theory and international best practices to support well-informed policy decisions and help identify priorities for economic development