-
Product type:
Analytical Document -
Authors:
-
Date:
25 June 2002 -
With financial support from:
The analysis of a draft on pension reform
Ukraine’s current Pay-As-You-Go (PAYG) pension system suffers from the problems that are common among other European transition countries:
-
Falling birthrates combined with low retirement age will contribute to deteriorating dependency ratio.
-
Lack of direct connection between the amount of benefits and the amount of contributions creates incentives for evasion.
-
The system is extremely complicated. A great number of privileged pension schemes make it non-transparent and difficult to administer.
Simulations of the effects of a draft of the law “On mandatory state pension insurance” showed that
-
The draft currently discussed in the parliament is more detrimental to the dependency ratio because it preserves current retirement age.
-
The draft preserves privileged pensions that undermine efficiency of the pension system.
-
Funded pillar is too small to alleviate the pressure of demographic changes on the PAYG pillar.
-
The proposed pension system turns out to be fiscally unsustainable. In the long run it would lead to large deficits.
We propose the following recommendations:
-
Review the pension privileges. If additional benefits are desirable, they should be funded from separate budget items, not from the pension fund.
-
Design an optimal transition to a higher retirement age consistent with international standards.
-
Introduce a funded pillar that significantly complements the PAYG pillar, with the perspective of investing in foreign financial markets.
IER Project
German Economic Team in Ukraine (GET)The project aims to develop economic policy recommendations for Ukraine based on rigorous analysis, contemporary economic theory and international best practices to support well-informed policy decisions and help identify priorities for economic development