Notes on the draft decree of the President of Ukraine “On ensuring the formation and functioning of agrarian markets”

  • Product type:

    Analytical Document
  • Authors:

    • Opitz Petra, Vincentz Volkhart, Striewe Ludwig, Schomerus Lorenz
  • Date:

    23 July 2000
  • With financial support from:

The draft decree addresses a number of very important issues related to the development of agricultural markets in Ukraine and the factors which have hindered this development in recent years. The development of commodity exchanges for agricultural products as well as wholesale and retail market structures for food products, the modernisation of market information systems and statistical reporting networks, and the improvement of education in the areas of agricultural economics and marketing are key priorities and it is, in principle, very positive that the decree stresses their importance.

The draft decree contains a number of very positive passages that deserved to be fleshed out and implemented as quickly as possible. The passages under article 2 that provide that the state only procure agricultural produce on a competitive basis and the call for non-interference in the activity of commercial structures, banning restrictions on agricultural product movements are of vital importance. The German Advisory Group has stressed repeatedly in recent months that the coming harvest will be a sort of litmus-test.

If government structures at the central or regional level interfere in the marketing of the grain harvest this fall, despite promises that this will not occur, then the already damaged credibility of Ukrainian agricultural policy in the eyes of domestic and foreign commercial actors will suffer a severe and perhaps fatal blow. If, on the other hand, the coming harvest is indeed marketed freely without any government interference, commercial actors will have concrete evidence that there has been a serious turn-around in agricultural policy in Ukraine. As a result, they will step up their activities, thus improving the basis for fall and spring field work in 2000 and 2001. These provisions of the draft decree must be implemented with rigour.

At the same time, however, we are concerned that the decree does not reflect a complete understanding of the role and limitations of government agricultural policy in a market economy. While the state is responsible in most market economies for the collection and dissemination of market information, and while the provision of secondary and higher education is generally regulated and financed by governments throughout the world, the state in a market economy is not responsible for the creation of networks of storage points, credit unions or service co-operatives. It is also not responsible for the creation of networks of retail trade stores for agricultural products such as supermarkets etc.

IER Project

German Economic Team in Ukraine (GET)

The project aims to develop economic policy recommendations for Ukraine based on rigorous analysis, contemporary economic theory and international best practices to support well-informed policy decisions and help identify priorities for economic development

Files for Download