-
Product type:
Analytical Document -
Authors:
-
Date:
23 July 2000 -
With financial support from:
A position on reforming the tax and budget codes
The government’s plans to lower tax rates to levels below those generally prevailing internationally, while broadening the tax base and aligning certain definitions and provisions in individual tax laws with Western European standards, could, in our view, give a meaningful boost to economic growth. The proposed introduction of low, uniform marginal tax rates is expected, according to modern economic theory, to provide strong incentives for economic activity and promote more efficient resource allocation.
At the same time, these potential benefits must be weighed against the risk of a widening budget deficit and financial instability resulting from lower tax revenues. We therefore favor a more gradual reduction in tax rates. In our view, setting both the corporate income tax rate and the top personal income tax rate at 25%, while keeping the current, relatively high value-added tax rate of 20% unchanged, would offer a sound and potentially optimal combination.
However, we believe that urgent measures could be taken to reduce the current accumulation of tax and other payment arrears to the state budget, thereby limiting the risks to financial stability.
Most of these arrears stem from:
- the private appropriation of revenues generated by state-owned enterprises;
- poor management, particularly at state-owned enterprises;
- monopolistic or oligopolistic market structures;
- non-monetary transactions.
The measures we consider necessary to address these arrears include:
- privatizing enterprises, including large ones, and breaking them up where necessary;
- establishing a new framework for effective oversight of state-owned enterprises and the exercise of state ownership rights;
- imposing certain restrictions on outside business activities by managers of state-owned enterprises;
- introducing effective penalties for enterprises that delay payments, including the threat of and recourse to bankruptcy proceedings;
- permanently prohibiting set-offs and non-monetary payments between enterprises, on the one hand, and budgetary institutions and the tax administration, on the other.
The full version of the document is available in German below.
IER Project
German Economic Team in Ukraine (GET)The project aims to develop economic policy recommendations for Ukraine based on rigorous analysis, contemporary economic theory and international best practices to support well-informed policy decisions and help identify priorities for economic development