Adjusting gas prices to unlock Ukraine’s economic potential

  • Product type:

    Analytical Document
  • Authors:

    • JörgRadeke, Ricardo Giucci, Dmytro Naumenko
  • Date:

    31 May 2012
  • With financial support from:

Ukraine imports gas from Russia at a price of USD 416 per thousand cubic metres (tcm). At the same time, gas is sold within Ukraine for a much lower price: Householdspay as little as 83 USD/tcm and heating companies  pay only 136 USD/tcm. This huge price mismatch has a wide range of severe economic effects. Firstly, the cost of gas price subsidies, including the administrative price setting of gas extracted in Ukraine at only 53 USD/tcm, add up to a massive 6% of GDP. This is money that needs to be paid for by the population through higher taxes or a lack of funding for health services, better education and infrastructure. Secondly, because low prices for households and heating companies encourage wasteful energy use, Ukraine needs to import over 74% of its gas demand.As such, subsidised gas prices are the single major economic and fiscal barrier to higher economic growth and prosperity in the country.

Given the high prices currently paid by Ukraine for its imported gas in comparison to Western European countries negotiating better terms is a legitimate undertaking. However, the fundamental problem will remain and there is little doubt that gas prices for households and heating companies have to be raised. In this context a number of crucial implementation questions arise: When to raise prices? By how much should prices be increased? Which other policy measures are necessary to accompany price rises? How to communicate this policy with the population in order achieve approval? The key for a successful price adjustment lies in finding the right answers to these questions.

A starting point in finding the right policy is the relationship between price and demand for gas. Economic theory and empirical evidence clearly show that demand for gas is high when the price of gas is low and vice versa. Thus, by increasing gas prices Ukraine can reduce gas demand and its need for imports. Falling gas demand would also go a long way in softening the impact on consumers’ energy bills.

However, the speed and the size of the reduction of demand following a price increase depend on a number of conditions. Indeed, the government can actively impact how demand will respond to rising prices. Firstly, the population has to understand that for many years to come gas (and heating) prices will increase (“one-way road”). This will create the strong incentives needed for reducing consumption and investing in energy efficiency. Consequently, policy makers should not just announce a one-off price increase, but a series of gradual price increases over the coming years. In order for this announcement to be credible the immediate price increase has to be substantial.

Secondly, the government at the central and local level has to create the technical preconditions for a swift reduction in demand. In particular, more meters need to be installed and other measures that allow  consumers to reduce demand are to be implemented swiftly. Cooperation with foreign international financial institutions and donors can provide substantial assistance here. By doing so, the government will show to the population that people are not let alone with higher prices and higher energy bills. This will contribute to a better acceptance of the measures.

It is necessary to implement a significant increase of gas prices in the nearest future. Once prices go up, the pressure on authorities “to do something” will increase and thus accelerate reforms. Postponing price increases until the technical preconditions are there is not an option, since without political pressure little will happen.

Keeping households’ energy bills low is a legitimate concern. However, instead of subsidising prices the government should help households to reduce the amount of energy they need. Doing so would signal a major policy shift and has the potential to solve one of Ukraine’s key economic problems. A much more favourable macroeconomic, fiscal and investment climate would be the result unlocking Ukraine’s enormous economic potential.

IER Project

German Economic Team in Ukraine (GET)

The project aims to develop economic policy recommendations for Ukraine based on rigorous analysis, contemporary economic theory and international best practices to support well-informed policy decisions and help identify priorities for economic development