Does Ukraine need a special law on re-privatisation?

  • Product type:

    Analytical Document
  • Authors:

    • Sugolov Pavlo, Akimova Iryna, Scherbakov Alexander
  • Date:

    25 January 2003
  • With financial support from:

According to international standards the definition of re-privatisation is pretty close to the definition of nationalisation. Common justifications for nationalisation are the “sick industry argument”; product quality, national security, and fair income redistribution considerations; regional development issues; and the solution of regulatory problems due to alleged market failure (e.g. externalities, yardstick competition).

As a rule, nationalisation is exercised on an industry-wide scale, and basically rules out insolvencies of “socially important” enterprises. However, the attempts to support industries in decay via direct ownership control by the state have only rarely turned out to be successful. In Ukraine, in contrast to western industrialised countries, re-privatisation disputes can primarily be attributed to the pitfalls of the privatisation program. Multiple cases of shadow privatisation, non-privatisation mechanisms of state property alienation via bankruptcy procedures, or violations of investment obligations have raised discussions about adopting a special law on re-privatisation.

We argue that a special law on re-privatisation is not recommendable at the moment, since a) most of the problems could be corrected through amendments and a better (more rigorous) implementation of the existing legislation; b) a focus on reprivatisation/ nationalisation issues could harm the investment climate, aggravate the non-transparency of the privatisation process, create additional opportunities for corruption, and serve as an instrument of re-distribution of attractive assets between the groups of owners according to the political interests of business elites. Instead, more emphasis should be put on a) setting up an appropriate regulatory framework for the infrastructure sectors and amending privatisation procedures for “sick” industries before their wide-scale privatisation has started; b) improving the implementation of the existing legislation that settles the cases of violation of privatisation rules; c) increasing the security of property rights.

IER Project

German Economic Team in Ukraine (GET)

The project aims to develop economic policy recommendations for Ukraine based on rigorous analysis, contemporary economic theory and international best practices to support well-informed policy decisions and help identify priorities for economic development

Files for Download