Efficiency and productivity growth in Ukrainian agriculture. Executive summary and recommendations

  • Product type:

    Analytical Document
  • Authors:

    • Demyanenko Serhiy, Galushko Victoria
  • Date:

    22 July 2003
  • With financial support from:

This paper presents the results of new methodology for calculating enterprise efficiency. This methodology is employed in market-oriented economies and is different from the methodology employed in Ukraine that uses as a starting point profitability rate and net profits per hectare of land.

The main findings of the efficiency analysis applied to agricultural enterprises are:

  • Total factor productivity growth is positively related to farm size. Even though large agricultural enterprises appear to be less efficient, they appear to experience greater efficiency improvements and to enjoy faster rates of technological progress compared to small farms. This finding is valuable for policy-makers because it, on the one hand, testifies that large-scale production is important for diffusing technology through agricultural sector and, on the other hand, calls for facilitating access to service and capital markets by small farms.
  • Of the four most important forms of ownership, cooperatives are the least technically efficient on average. This finding suggests that structural change in Ukrainian agriculture will lead to cooperatives being gradually replaced by more efficient forms of ownership such as private enterprises and agricultural companies.
  • The average value of technical efficiency in Ukrainian agriculture is rather low. Inefficiency arises due to over-utilization of all resources. Thus, it is important for agricultural producers to learn to economize on resources. Investments into research, training programs for farmers and agricultural education need to be increased in order to ensure that managers and farmers make the best possible use of the existent capital stock and quickly learn to operate modern technologies. Further, average efficiency scores are very low because they are pulled down by a fairly large number of highly inefficient enterprises. These farms should face more pressure to either increase efficiency or exit agriculture. To this end policy-makers should direct their efforts to the elimination of input market imperfections, since competitive markets are the most flexible and efficient mechanism for allocating resources. For example, the existence of a well functioning land market would enable farmers to allocate land to more efficient uses.
  • By supporting agricultural producers by, for example with subsidized credits, the government can encourage investments into capital stock and, consequently, technological progress. However, this will not necessarily result in increased efficiency in an economic sense, because government support will create incentives for managers to put more of their efforts into securing this support rather then improving production efficiency. Furthermore, since technological progress is, to a great extent, a matter of catching-up with modern technologies, the creation of favorable conditions to attract especially foreign investment into agriculture as a means of transferring innovations and know-how is more important than direct government support.

IER Project

German Economic Team in Ukraine (GET)

The project aims to develop economic policy recommendations for Ukraine based on rigorous analysis, contemporary economic theory and international best practices to support well-informed policy decisions and help identify priorities for economic development

Files for Download