How to determine concession fees? Current methodology cannot be improved without changes in attitude to concession bidding

  • Product type:

    Analytical Document
  • Authors:

    • Sugolov Pavlo
  • Date:

    24 March 2002
  • With financial support from:

Governments of increasing number of countries pursue deregulation and private sector involvement as a measure to increase efficiency of infrastructure industries. However, exclusively private project financing has failed as an instrument of infrastructure development. New ways of public-private partnership (PPP) has developed into a very wide variety of forms – service contracts, management contracts, lease agreements, concession contracts, Build-Operate-Transfer contracts, Build-Operate-Own contracts, and finally divestiture. Forms of PPP vary depending on a sector and a country, but the most widespread forms are management contracts, lease agreements and concession contracts. At the same time concession contracts lead in number in water supply and road sectors. Concession contracts provision investment commitment of a concessionaire in exchange for the right to posses profit generated by the concession. Under this arrangement an object of the concession remains in state ownership.

Ukrainian government, following positive experience of PPP in the form of concession, has proposed for concession a number of highways construction projects along international transportation corridors as well as a number of water supply construction and rehabilitation projects. However, no projects have been implemented in Ukraine so far (not taking into account one project started in road sector before current legislation adoption). At the same time, in Ukraine foreign investors and international financial institutions seek for water and road rehabilitation projects in the form of service and management contracts (Kherson, Mariupol). In the latter cases the government bears operational and investment risks, failing to shift them to private investors.

It is understandable that the major impediment to investments into concession projects in Ukraine is unstable macroeconomic and regulatory environment, which increases political risks. However, an additional negative impact produces incomplete legislation on concessions. Notwithstanding the adopted Laws “On Concessions”, “Concessions for Roads” and a number of the Cabinet of Ministers decrees, which develop the regulations of the Laws, it can be concluded that there is still much to be done. In particular, current legislation fails to create competition for the market through concession bidding. The legislation does not oblige the government to prepare a project proposal for a concession and further to organize concession bidding for it.

IER Project

German Economic Team in Ukraine (GET)

The project aims to develop economic policy recommendations for Ukraine based on rigorous analysis, contemporary economic theory and international best practices to support well-informed policy decisions and help identify priorities for economic development

Files for Download