-
Product type:
Analytical Document -
Authors:
-
Date:
09 December 2003 -
With financial support from:
Institutional aspects of land market development in Ukraine
The status of land as private property has been institutionalised in Ukraine in recent years, which is a positive results of the agricultural land privatisation process. More than half of the land property certificates of former Kolkhoz members have already been transformed into state deeds on land property. But this is only the first step on the way of building a market for agricultural land. At the moment, land sales are prohibited by a moratorium which will expire on Jan 1st 2005. In order to finalize the privatisation process and enable a properly functioning land market in the future, Ukrainian lawmakers have to design an institutional framework for land market transactions, both for land sales and tenure, by January 2004. Important activities to be carried out within this institutional framework are:
- cadastral monitoring,
- land use planning in the framework of the respective legislation,
- registration of land property rights,
- registration of mortgages and other duties connected with ownership,
- settling of legal conflicts.
International experience shows that there is no unique optimal example for such an institutional framework. Ukraine has decided to delegate this task to the State Committee of Land Resources (SCLR), thereby choosing a centralised approach instead of a multi-agency approach which has also been under discussion. However, a lack of constitutional checks and balances within this institutional set-up, and, consequently, a concentration of power within SCLR could be a consequence of this concentration of competences and tasks. Given the peculiarities in Ukraine, we would like to recommend the following guidelines:
- Efficiency: it should guarantee cheap and not too lengthy transactions by restricting the number of necessary bureaucratic procedures. Efficiency is best achieved by creating one national public organization with local branches for the registration of all land transactions.
- Checks and balances among constitutional powers: the system should be governed by the rule of law, and conflicts of interest of the state organizations involved should be ruled out. Strengthening the position of the local registrar whose decisions should be challengeable solely by the local courts upon appeal, and not to the SCLR, even though he/she will be working within this structure in order to guarantee “short ways” for clients and procedures. The SCLR or its structural unit, the Centre of the State Land Cadastre, should be accountable to the legislative power (e.g. a special commission of V.R. or a body authorized by the legislative power).
IER Project
German Economic Team in Ukraine (GET)The project aims to develop economic policy recommendations for Ukraine based on rigorous analysis, contemporary economic theory and international best practices to support well-informed policy decisions and help identify priorities for economic development