Is the Ukrainian-Russian gas consortium in the economic interest of Ukraine?

  • Product type:

    Analytical Document
  • Authors:

    • Christian von Hirschhausen, Pavel Ferdinand, Ivan Poltavets
  • Date:

    25 April 2003
  • With financial support from:

Our paper analyzes the economic effects of the recently concluded gas consortium between Russia and Ukraine, which aims at the joint management of the Gas Transit System (GTS). In particular, we are concerned about whether or not this decision is in the economic interest of Ukraine given expected changes on the market for natural gas in Western Europe.

We therefore use a model in which Russia competes with Norwegian and Algerian gas exports on the European market, and where Ukraine sets its transit fee either a) separately from Russia (as it is currently the case); or b) jointly with Russia within the consortium. For a projection period between 2010 and 2015 we find that:

  • Increased competition within the EU weakens both Russia and Ukraine, as Algeria and Norway will expand their market shares.
  • Higher bypass capacities around Ukraine (56 bcm through Belarus) are favorable for Russia but cut profits for Ukraine by almost 50%.
  • An expansion of demand levels in Western Europe slightly benefits Ukraine, but expected gains are not high enough to compensate for losses from the two previous effects.

The aggregate outcome of all those developments is that if Ukraine continues setting transit fees separately from Russia its annual net profits will drop by around USD 80 m compared to 2001. In contrast, operating the GTS jointly within a consortium will reduce transit costs thereby allowing for higher volumes. As a result, overall profits of the pipeline will increase so that both, Russia and Ukraine can make higher profits than in 2001. Assuming that Ukraine receives an appropriate share of those joint profits, additional annual revenues might exceed some USD 500 m. At the end, we discuss necessary conditions to ensure such a fair and transparent profit-sharing agreement between the two countries.

IER Project

German Economic Team in Ukraine (GET)

The project aims to develop economic policy recommendations for Ukraine based on rigorous analysis, contemporary economic theory and international best practices to support well-informed policy decisions and help identify priorities for economic development

Files for Download