Non-conventional gas regulation in Europe: implications for Ukraine

  • Product type:

    Analytical Document
  • Authors:

    • Frank Meißner, Dmytro Naumenko
  • Date:

    01 May 2011
  • With financial support from:

Non-conventional gas may become a significant part of national energy supply in Ukraine in the next decades. Thereby, this type of resource can be applied as complement to national conventional natural gas and may be used as a substitute in the long run.

The utilisation of given non-conventional potentials in Ukraine requires elaborating a long-term strategy, which takes into account the economic and technical challenges and the extensive environmental hazards. A clear regulatory framework is necessary for the attraction of investments, for creating public acceptance, and for an economical use of natural finite resources.

We revise the EU progress regarding non-conventional gas regulation, and introduce the existing regulatory framework in the EU27 and in the Member States since they might be useful for Ukraine.

In view of the European development it emerges that regulations are necessary regarding (1) mining, (2) property rights, (3) fresh water use, (4) habitat and biodiversity hazards, and (5) waste management.

Whether non-conventional gas will play the  predicted dominant role in European and Ukrainian energy supplies will mainly be influenced by the development of gas prices and the technical progress in non-conventional gas production, which reduces costs.

The further European demand on natural gas (conventional and possibly non-conventional) will influence the technical progress of mining, the amount of firms in the sector, and thereby gas prices. Obviously, the European overall gas demand resp. the share of natural gas in the energy mix (as discussed in section 3) will have a major impact on how much non-conventional gas will be demanded. This gas demand also depends on further steps regarding European climate targets, global energy price development, cost of drilling and several environmental issues regarding non-conventional gas. Furthermore, the uncertainties related to nuclear power plants’ safety represent a major challenge for the European energy resp. electricity strategy.

Environmental hazards are one major obstacle in the development of non-conventional production in Europe. Public acceptance is  mainly influenced by concerns about water pollution and habitat destruction. Strict environmental rules for non-conventional production in Ukraine can help to reduce risks and to ensure public acceptance, which has a positive impact on investors’ reputation and thereby investors’ decisions.

Summarizing, we recommend the following Ukrainian policies on non-conventional gas:

(1) Observe the international progresses and learn from successes and failures, (2) Perform a fundamental investigation of national reserves, (3) Develop the basis of a regulatory frame for exploration and production of non-conventional gas resp. clarify if existing regulations on conventional gas is applicable for non-conventional gas production, (4) Improve the legislative framework for foreign investments  attraction to non-conventional sector for participation in knowledge and technology transfer, (5) Establish the legislative framework for public participation process.

IER Project

German Economic Team in Ukraine (GET)

The project aims to develop economic policy recommendations for Ukraine based on rigorous analysis, contemporary economic theory and international best practices to support well-informed policy decisions and help identify priorities for economic development