Public private partnership as alternative to privatization, with an application to OJSC “Ukrtelecom”

  • Product type:

    Analytical Document
  • Authors:

    • Verstyuk Sergiy, Verstyuk Sergiy, Scherbakov Alexander, Pavel Ferdinand
  • Date:

    25 January 2003
  • With financial support from:

The frequent failure of large-scale privatization in Ukraine can only in part be explained by the global economic downturn. Rather, low demand for state-owned assets by foreign investors is caused by high, country- and company-specific uncertainty (due to unstable regulatory environment, low government commitment to a particular policy, low financial transparency of state-owned enterprises, uncertain relations with suppliers etc.).

To reduce such uncertainty we suggest replacing immediate privatization by a two-stage procedure: In the first-an “initial trial” period- a potential investor participates in a (temporarily limited) Public Private Partnership (PPP) agreement and operates a state-owned firm/asset to asses “true” risks and “true” profitability without having to make any definite long-term financial commitments. Given that the experiences turn out to be positive, the second phase”regular privatization” then allows the investor to purchase the firm or asset at conditions, which are more beneficial for both sides.

Because contract design of PPP arrangements has proven to be crucial for their success, we discuss the main components and types. First, PPPs differ by the extent to which responsibilities and risks of operating a joint project are allocated between public and private partners. Further crucial components are those of regulation and bidding procedures. While discussing them in detail we also stress that they must be combined in a well-elaborated way, which depends on the overall purpose of the PPP. Finally, to demonstrate the applicability of our suggestion we discuss how OJSC “Ukrtelecom” could be operated in a partnership between the state and a private investor. As we suggest, such a proceeding would-provided the agreement is set up in a proper way-reduce uncertainty for the investor thus stimulating interest in the privatization of “Ukrtelecom” in the second phase.

IER Project

German Economic Team in Ukraine (GET)

The project aims to develop economic policy recommendations for Ukraine based on rigorous analysis, contemporary economic theory and international best practices to support well-informed policy decisions and help identify priorities for economic development

Files for Download