Regulatory scheme for utilities: proposal for Ukraine

  • Product type:

    Analytical Document
  • Authors:

    • IER experts
  • Date:

    06 November 2005
  • With financial support from:

Unprofitable frame conditions in Ukraine’s utilities sector, frequent political interventions into price setting as well as the lack of strong political will to implement structural reforms diminish significantly the attractiveness of the sector for investments. To solve these problems it is necessary to ensure transparent and reliable conditions for economic activities in the sector. Ukrainian policy makers have increasingly realized that this can best be achieved by introducing an independent regulatory scheme. The construction of an appropriate regulatory scheme is not a trivial task. In fact, answering the question of “how to regulate?” appears to be much more important than solving the issue of “who regulates?”, on which the current political debate tends to focus.

For the case of the utility sector in Ukraine we believe that regulation should simultaneously achieve three important goals. It should ensure that prices are cost-covering, it should give incentives to reduce costs, and it should stimulate (and, if necessary, force) firms to improve management and factor productivity. Against this background, we propose Yardstick competition as the appropriate regulatory mechanism. As this scheme is rather complex to introduce, we also outline a strategy for its gradual introduction over a 3-5 years period. Moreover, based on a unique data set on Ukrainian Vodokanals we demonstrate the methodology that the regulator should use and show how this approach can be made operational for the case of Ukraine. Although our analysis is rather preliminary in nature, it already provides robust and meaningful results. This should be used as a basis for additional and more sophisticated quantitative work.

IER Project

German Economic Team in Ukraine (GET)

The project aims to develop economic policy recommendations for Ukraine based on rigorous analysis, contemporary economic theory and international best practices to support well-informed policy decisions and help identify priorities for economic development

Files for Download