Should a “strong Ukrainian grain trader” be established?

  • Product type:

    Analytical Document
  • Authors:

    • Kuhn Arnim
  • Date:

    14 July 2003
  • With financial support from:

In the wake of the most recent developments in Ukrainian grain markets (volatile prices and export volumes) the activity of foreign grain trade companies is being observed with mistrust, assuming that these companies charge Ukrainian farmers low prices and realise huge profits which are drained outside the country. At the same time the idea of establishing a “strong Ukrainian grain trader” has been revived. KHLIB UKRAINY would probably be a candidate organisation for becoming something as the “Ukrainian Wheat Board”. However, grain markets in Ukraine as well as in other places in the world are highly competitive, which causes profit margins to be relatively small. This means that the opportunities for grain traders to exploit farmers or consumers are strongly limited as long as they are not granted a monopoly position by the state. Since such a monopoly is exactly the idea behind establishing a grain board, neither farmers nor consumers or taxpayers are likely to benefit from such a “strong Ukrainian trader”.

Recommendations

  1. The government should resist the temptation to turn Khlib Ukrainy into a monopoly grain board. Such institutions tend to become a burden to both farmers and taxpayers.
  2. Most importantly, the state has to ensure that contracts between private agents have to be fulfilled. This decreases the uncertainty component in trade margins.
  3. In the case of the grain, the government has to make sure that competition governs the market, thereby preventing both domestic and foreign companies from exercising pricing power and realising excessive profits. Some current problems are caused not by too much but rather too little competition, i.e. by continued formal and informal intervention on grain markets in Ukraine by regional authorities.
  4. The agricultural ministry should establish and constantly improve market information systems for farmers and other agents in the market. Better market information ensures a level playing field for all market participants and ensures that all can make better decisions for the future.

IER Project

German Economic Team in Ukraine (GET)

The project aims to develop economic policy recommendations for Ukraine based on rigorous analysis, contemporary economic theory and international best practices to support well-informed policy decisions and help identify priorities for economic development

Files for Download