-
Product type:
Analytical Document -
Authors:
-
Date:
15 October 2003 -
With financial support from:
The 2003 wheat crisis and food security
Recent developments on the Ukrainian food market have been marked by a sharp increase in wholesale and retail prices for the majority of food products. Food price increases could not leave poor consumers unaffected, and have caused widespread public concern. As a result, government agricultural policy has been re-oriented towards more intensive administrative interference. Nevertheless, even though government policy of ensuring “affordable” food prices to consumers is intended to protect the poorest who depend on inexpensive staple food to survive, it poorly succeeds in reaching the target groups, that is, low-income households. Instead most of the benefits from low-priced food accrue to the rich.
Recommendations
- Food market policies such as setting price ceilings, regulating profitability and mark-ups are ineffective policy tools that do not primarily reach the most vulnerable groups. As a short-run solution, the appropriate targeting of the poor through general welfare schemes and food stamps would be the best and the cheapest way of promoting food security and protecting poor consumers: food stamp program would cost twice as less as the alternative policy, which is being discussed nowadays, – the elimination of VAT on bread.
- Direct price controls and restrictions on grain movements simply fragment markets, boost the shadow economy and undermine market-oriented reforms. A contrary policy, i.e. pursuing the common (integrated) market would alleviate short-run regional shortages and strengthen competition among regional agricultural and food producers, thus leading to both lower food prices and higher per capita incomes for farmers.
- Rather than forcing producers to operate at low rates of profitability, ensuring competition on regional markets for flour and bread is best suited to prevent possible excess profits and keep prices at a level where they reflect the true scarcities.
- A long-term goal should be a reduction in production variability. To this end investment into agricultural research and extension should be increased, since this would help introduction of drought-resistant and high-yield crop varieties and would help diversify production, thus reducing vulnerability to price shocks.
- In order to reduce price fluctuations for agricultural commodities and food products, transaction costs should be reduced. To this end the whole transportation system should be improved and bureaucratic obstacles removed.
- Storage of 2 m tons of grain could prevent serious grain shortage. However, holding buffer stocks is not the best way to stabilize prices, since during the high price phases stock releases would probably not affect price but instead simply substitute for commercial imports. Furthermore, due to uncertainty regarding which crop will be in shortage it is not clear the stocks of which crops should be accumulated, which adds to uncertainty regarding the effectiveness of buffer stocks.
IER Project
German Economic Team in Ukraine (GET)The project aims to develop economic policy recommendations for Ukraine based on rigorous analysis, contemporary economic theory and international best practices to support well-informed policy decisions and help identify priorities for economic development