-
Product type:
Analytical Document -
Authors:
-
Date:
27 September 2003 -
With financial support from:
The situation on Ukraine’s grain market: crisis! What crisis?
Due to a poor grain harvest this year Ukraine has become a net importer of food grain in 2003/2004. This has lead to an increase in grain prices and generated a sense of “crisis” among the public. However, taking into consideration the measures that the government has undertaken it may be more appropriate to speak of a crisis in agricultural policy making in Ukraine than of a crisis in Ukrainian agriculture:
- By emphasising individual responsibility the government has sustained the myth that people can control markets and created an atmosphere in which each bureaucrat is eager to appear active in monitoring the market and eliminating alleged market failures. The result has been more, not less market failure.
- Government interference in the form of price, profitability rate, markups and grain movement controls has done nothing to correct the situation on the market but, on the contrary, has further disbalanced and fragmented markets.
- Announcements that the government intends to purchase grain are counterproductive. What Ukraine needs now is not more demand on its grain markets, but rather more supply.
- Opacity and vagueness of government policy regarding grain imports has slowed down imports by private firms, thus reducing supply and increasing prices even more.
- In general, many recent measures cast doubt on Ukraine’s continued commitment to market-driven agricultural reform and restructuring. If administrative controls continue to be tightened, then the 2003 harvest will be remembered no only for the immediate hardship that it caused.
The inescapable fact is that Ukraine will have to import food grain in the 2003/04 season. In essence, policy makers should adopt the maxim “less is more”. The last months of hectic and often counterproductive activity have done nothing to correct the fundamental problem that Ukraine has brought in a bad harvest, that it must therefore import grain, and that this grain is currently expensive on world markets. Indeed, there is nothing that any policy maker or any number of emergency meetings can do to change any of these basic facts. Hence, all that agricultural policy can do is to ensure that prices in Ukraine do not increase any more than necessary by facilitating imports, and to ensure that as much help as possible is channelled towards those individuals and households for whom the current situation creates true hardship.
IER Project
German Economic Team in Ukraine (GET)The project aims to develop economic policy recommendations for Ukraine based on rigorous analysis, contemporary economic theory and international best practices to support well-informed policy decisions and help identify priorities for economic development