VAT refund crisis In Ukraine: causes, risks, and solutions

  • Product type:

    Analytical Document
  • Authors:

    • Nina Legeida, Roman Chekh
  • Date:

    24 March 2002
  • With financial support from:

Since 1998, the performance of the Value Added Tax (VAT) system in Ukraine has been deteriorating. The business sector has accumulated large arrears it owes to the government, firms are unable to recover VAT refunds, and the whole situation is obscured by rampant fraud and corruption. While the scale of the problem in Ukraine is unique, the causes can be identified clearly. Because similar problems have occurred in other countries, a considerable international experience with proper solutions exists.

The VAT problem damages the Ukrainian economy in many ways. It interferes with cash flows firms use to finance their daily operations, and it undermines the competitive edge of exports on which economic growth in Ukraine depends. It also reduces government’s revenues, and it deters foreign investors from doing business in Ukraine. But perhaps the greatest and most serious damage is done to Ukraine’s price system. The practice of complicated tax privileges, write-offs, offsets, schemes and wechsels is a step back to the mechanism in which non-transparent, non-cash transactions enabled massive redistribution of funds that drain public finance and evade scrutiny by the government and by the public. What’s more, such practices make tracking the true debt position of firms impossible, introducing bias into the privatization process, bankruptcy proceedings, etc.

That is why this problem deserves immediate attention of Ukraine’s leadership. The VAT refund debt is de facto a loan the government borrowed from businesses and used it to finance its spending. It is therefore crucial that the government restores the transparency of VAT. Unfortunately, there are no quick and easy solutions for these problems. The purpose of this paper is to provide a concise overview of the causes that led to this crisis, the risks that this crisis brings, and, most importantly, the steps that will solve these problems.

As the following paragraphs show, the VAT problem presents the political leadership of Ukraine with a difficult challenge, but also with a unique opportunity. Implementing the steps leading to the solution of this problem will provide a clear signal to the Ukrainian society, as well as to the international community, that the government of Ukraine is committed to economic reform.

IER Project

German Economic Team in Ukraine (GET)

The project aims to develop economic policy recommendations for Ukraine based on rigorous analysis, contemporary economic theory and international best practices to support well-informed policy decisions and help identify priorities for economic development

Files for Download