Wheat market stabilisation: options for Ukraine

  • Product type:

    Analytical Document
  • Authors:

    • von Cramon-Taubadel Stephan
  • Date:

    23 December 2003
  • With financial support from:

Ukraine has harvested roughly 4,2 million tonnes of wheat in 2003, its worst wheat crop in decades. Policy makers in Ukraine have responded to this situation with a series of measures in recent months, many of which have actually limited the ability of markets to respond and relieve the current situation. Instead, they have sharpened shortages of wheat on Ukrainian markets and driven prices higher than necessary, as they have created insecurity on the part of importers and thus delayed necessary wheat imports while world market prices were continuously rising.

Even though it is hoped that the increasing productivity of Ukraine’s wheat production will make such a situation less and less likely in the future, the Ukrainian government can take measures today which can dramatically alleviate future grain shortages. Our recommendations related to this policy area are:

  • Lengthy parliamentary decision processes are not suited to deal with a grain shortage. Trade policies should be generally prepared for such a shortage in order to allow necessary imports in time.
  • The import tariff on wheat is completely useless and should be abolished, as it is either dysfunctional (in a normal export situation) or politically unbearable in case of a need for imports when it drives bread prices further up.
  • The chance to benefit from special export facilitation programmes of the USA or the EU should not be missed, but only if they do not restrict the freedom of Ukraine to export grain after the next harvesting season. Furthermore, negotiations leading to such deals should not be allowed to increase uncertainty and further delay necessary commercial imports.
  • The temporary exemption from VAT is predominantly attractive to traders with claims on VAT refunds from earlier export deals. Moreover, it reintroduces an element of mutual debt-setoff with budget entities, the latter which has been largely criticised and recently been ruled out by law.
  • Agricultural policy should make the reduction of transport, handling, and various other trade costs within Ukraine a top priority.

IER Project

German Economic Team in Ukraine (GET)

The project aims to develop economic policy recommendations for Ukraine based on rigorous analysis, contemporary economic theory and international best practices to support well-informed policy decisions and help identify priorities for economic development

Files for Download