In September, the NGO Technologies of Progress and the Institute for Economic Research and Policy Consulting (IER), with the support of the European Union, held a meeting bringing together civil society organisations as part of the Public Investment Watchdog project. Representatives of six NGOs monitoring public investment projects across the regions presented the first results of their work.
Mykolaiv and Cherkasy regions, NGO Against Corruption
According to the NGO, there are 1,323 public investment projects in Cherkasy and Mykolaiv regions. For detailed monitoring, the team selected 30 projects in Mykolaiv region and 40 in Cherkasy region.
Mykolaiv region proved more open to public monitoring: local communities are receptive, actively engage donors, and are gradually moving from formal compliance with requirements towards the practical implementation of energy efficiency, accessibility and transparency principles. According to Alona Prylutskа, Communications Manager at NGO Against Corruption, communities in Mykolaiv region no longer perceive public monitoring as a threat, but rather as a form of assistance.
As an example of good practice, Prylutskа cited a facility nearing completion, equipped with a lift and thoughtful design solutions. A representative of the Mykolaiv Regional Military Administration who accompanied the NGO’s experts during the site visit also specifically thanked them for their safety recommendations.
Another positive example of cooperation between local authorities and civil society is Stepivska community, which provided more than 100 pages of documents in response to the NGO’s request and openly reported that only 5% of the work had been completed due to the need to revise the project.
At the same time, there are also problem areas: information about the plans of local investment councils is not always available on community websites, making monitoring more difficult.
According to experts from NGO Against Corruption, Cherkasy region is less open to public monitoring. On the one hand, communities in Zolotonosha and Uman districts demonstrate a high level of transparency. On the other hand, Smila community does not have an investment council, public investment projects often go through the required stages only as a formality, data on project implementation are not updated, and some decisions are not made public. During site visits, the local education department also prohibited the NGO’s experts from taking photographs or recording video.
The only facility the experts were allowed to visit was a local outpatient clinic. It formally has accessibility features – ramps, signs and lifts – but actual access remains limited. During the renovation of the third floor, no lift was installed. Instead, a separate room for people with reduced mobility was set up on the first floor – a solution that saved money but did not fully resolve the accessibility issue. The lift providing access to the upper floors was locked during the visit, meaning that a wheelchair user could not use it independently.
“Overall, monitoring visits encourage representatives of communities and public institutions to think about whether all people will actually be able to use the infrastructure being created – because that is precisely what public investment is about,” said Alona Horbenko.
Kyiv and Chernihiv regions, NGO Institute for Sustainable Community Development
The NGO Institute for Sustainable Community Development monitors public investment projects in Kyiv and Chernihiv regions, comparing the pace of recovery in two regions that experienced occupation. The selection criteria were projects worth at least UAH 30 million that were already under implementation and had funding allocated for 2026. The experts concluded that Kyiv region is actively rebuilding, while Chernihiv region is lagging behind.
Under these criteria, the team was able to identify only around five projects worth more than UAH 30 million in Chernihiv region. The region lagged behind others both in the number of projects and in the volume of funding, while Kyiv region was among the leaders.
“Zaporizhzhia region is also worth noting, as it is effectively using its status as a frontline region to attract investment, unlike Chernihiv region, which, despite the scale of its challenges – including sharing a border with two countries – receives significantly less attention from donors,” noted Mykhailyna Skoryk-Shkarivska, Director of the Institute for Sustainable Community Development.
Overall, however, the team reached a cautiously optimistic conclusion: all community representatives interviewed understand the logic of the public investment reform and are adapting their budget processes accordingly. According to the speaker, none of the communities examined had “failed” the first year of the reform.
At the same time, a number of systemic problems were identified at the individual project level:
- Formal strategies. Many communities have not updated their development strategies, project assessments are largely formal, and implementation plans do not contain realistic timelines.
- Disproportionate funding. Under the Ukraine Recovery Programme, 48 projects in communities in Kyiv region and 6 in Chernihiv region received only UAH 3 million each, despite the total cost of these projects ranging from UAH 40 million to UAH 240 million. As of 31 August, this created a high risk of prolonged construction delays, particularly in light of the Government’s September decision to suspend capital spending until December.
According to Skoryk-Shkarivska, the new building of Lyceum No. 2 in Bucha was originally due to be completed on 5 January 2026, but completion has now been postponed until early 2027. Construction has effectively been at a standstill since June.
The new building of the Education Centre in Irpin was supposed to be completed by July 2026, but the project started late, the existing building was demolished, and construction work has still not begun.
Another example is the central city hospital project in Fastiv, worth UAH 200 million, which has so far received only UAH 3 million. The roof and insulation remain unfinished, with the project due to be completed by December 2026.
The NGO team recommends improving the funding model for selected projects, particularly those included in the national list of strategic priority investments. Public confidence in the reform depends to a large extent on whether funding actually reaches projects that have been approved and verified.
Volyn and Rivne regions, NGO Anti-Corruption Headquarters
The overall trend identified by the Anti-Corruption Headquarters team in the two regions is that up-to-date strategic documents are more common in larger communities, while in smaller communities work on development strategies has either only recently begun or remains unfinished. Novovolynsk community openly reported that it does not have its own strategy and relies on the regional strategy.
Anti-Corruption Headquarters expert Lidiia-Mariia Kich notes that competition among contractors in tenders is low in both regions: in most cases, only one contractor bids for a project, even in large tenders. One example is the construction of a new hospital building in Lypyny worth UAH 400 million, where there was virtually no competition, and the team identified certain risks related to the contractor itself.
The village of Kniahynynok near Lutsk provides a good example of flexibility, with the community focusing on people’s actual needs rather than simply seeking to spend allocated funds.
Initially, the community planned to allocate UAH 12.8 million to renovate the dining hall at a local school. However, it revised its priorities in favour of a UAH 3.5 million shelter after critical problems were identified: inadequate ventilation and drainage, flooding, the risk of mould and the potential complete deterioration of the premises. The issue is particularly important because the school effectively operates as a boarding school: 200 of its 440 pupils live there permanently.
The quality of implementation is one of the project’s strengths. The tender was announced in June, the contract was signed in July, and work began immediately. During the NGO’s second monitoring visit in September, the school principal reported that the facility was 96% complete. A minor delay had been caused by attacks on the contractor’s warehouses in Kyiv, which disrupted the supply of construction materials.
The project includes several quality solutions: alternative lighting sources in case of power outages; ventilation systems with both manual and automatic modes, including a response mechanism in the event of a possible strike; and internet access in every room of the shelter to ensure continuity of education. There is also a separate accessible room with a wider entrance, two entrances to the shelter, a wheelchair ramp (although independent access is not possible and assistance is required), and special rubber ramps to smooth out changes in floor levels in the 1960s building. In addition, the school principal gave the Anti-Corruption Headquarters team an extensive interview and provided a detailed tour of the facility.
Sumy, Kirovohrad, Khmelnytskyi and Chernivtsi regions, NGO Centre for Innovations Development
Mykhailo Leichenko, Director of IT and Analytics at the NGO Centre for Innovations Development, presented the experience of monitoring 15 public investment projects selected from approximately 1,500 projects in seven territorial communities. The total value of the monitored projects is UAH 1.7 billion. All of them are multi-component projects combining at least 2–4 facilities, while one project includes as many as eight facilities.
According to Leichenko, communities face four key obstacles when implementing public investment projects:
Funding. The problem is not so much finding funding as ensuring that the money actually reaches recipients during implementation – particularly in New Ukrainian School (NUS) projects, where, according to the Centre for Innovations Development, the Ministry of Education significantly delays payments. Funding amounts also often change because of “hidden works” – when a contractor discovers unforeseen problems during construction, such as the condition of the foundations or insulation, creating discrepancies between the estimated and actual funding requirements.
Contractors and tenders. A major problem is contractors who win regional tenders by submitting artificially low bids, receive the first tranche (10% under the contract), and then disappear without implementing the project. This results in stalled construction, criminal proceedings, termination of contracts and repeated tenders. Another systemic problem is the failure of military and local administrations to recognise such contractors as critical, creating a risk that there will not be enough workers available at project sites in the future.
Community capacity does not depend on size. Even very small communities, with populations of around 3,000, can sometimes advise larger communities serving as district centres. It all depends on the people involved and their level of engagement, rather than on the community’s formal status.
Documentation discrepancies. A key problem concerns the treatment of VAT in design and cost-estimate documentation: VAT is included in the overall methodology but is not actually broken down by individual items, appearing only as a single aggregate line. In one project, discrepancies were identified between data in the DREAM system, the project and cost-estimate documentation, and subcontractor documentation – including discrepancies in funding and calculations for operational or design works. There is currently no straightforward solution to this problem; synchronisation is possible only if the information is reconciled with the Ministry of Finance documents submitted by communities in their budget-use monitoring reports. The team also identified discrepancies between information in documents, procurement records and different accounting systems. When the team asks a community which figure is correct, there is often no clear answer.
Other problematic practices include the lack of clearly defined criteria for what constitutes the “start” and “completion” of a project, which are not established either in legislation or in the methodology; discrepancies between plans in official documents, the actual state of works and the terms of signed contracts; and incomplete alignment between contractors, documentation and cost estimates. The team recommends that communities maintain at least a simple internal document register that is clear to everyone involved.
Logistical and security restrictions on travel are also frequent obstacles to monitoring itself, as is the “fragmentation of roles” – when the people listed in DREAM as project initiators and implementers turn out in practice to be entirely different individuals. The Centre for Innovations Development team follows the principle of prioritising documents over verbal explanations: if a community does not provide documentary evidence to support its statements, this is recorded and made public.
Another recommendation from the NGO to communities is to encourage them to combine small projects worth UAH 500,000–3 million into larger multi-component projects. This would make it possible to move from monitoring individual amounts to systematic monitoring of public investment. Communities also often overlook alternative sources of financing, such as ESCO contracts, beyond the conventional four sources: public-private partnerships, grant and loan financing, and local and state budgets.
Ternopil and Lviv regions, NGO Women in Ukraine
In Ternopil region, NGO Women in Ukraine examined eight public investment projects in six communities, excluding the city of Ternopil itself: three secondary education facilities, two preschools and three administrative buildings housing Centres for the Provision of Administrative Services (CNAPs). The facilities were selected from among projects that already had funding, and a significant proportion were 80–90% complete.
During the monitoring visits, the team noted high-quality implementation of accessibility and energy-efficiency principles. For example, in Trybukhivtsi community, an expert who uses a wheelchair was specifically invited to test the CNAP and check all accessibility features. The three CNAPs are financed under the Ukraine Municipal Infrastructure Emergency Credit Programme of the European Investment Bank. According to Tetiana Dolishna, Director of the NGO, community leaders in Ternopil region demonstrated a relatively high degree of openness: all of them provided documentation and willingly showed the facilities to the monitoring team.
In Lviv region, Women in Ukraine examined seven public investment projects in two communities – Lviv and Stryi. All were educational facilities: five secondary schools and two sports facilities at schools.
Lviv plans to complete this year, using local budget funds, all projects launched before 2025, so that it can focus on new projects next year. The expert team noted the city’s systematic approach: projects go through a full approval process involving the relevant departments of the city administration rather than being approved merely as a formality. Particular attention is paid to promoting healthy lifestyles: the monitored facilities include a swimming pool at Ivan Poliui Lyceum and a sports ground at School No. 77. All of the facilities are worth more than UAH 10 million.
The most notable project is a school in Briukhovychi that has been under construction for more than 20 years and is financed by the EIB. It is finally nearing completion. Following the incorporation of Briukhovychi into the Lviv community, the city is particularly interested in seeing the project completed successfully.
Accessibility is being implemented systematically in Lviv’s projects. For example, the swimming pool at Ivan Poliui School has special lifting devices for people with reduced mobility and a sufficient number of specialised wheelchairs. The school in Briukhovychi has separate lifts of different widths for the primary and secondary school sections.
In Stryi, the team monitored two lyceums. Renovation work is financed from the local budget, while equipment is purchased through the New Ukrainian School programme.
Most of the facilities monitored by the team are expected to be completed by the end of the year. Some projects, particularly those involving transitional funding, were deliberately reclassified by the community as public investment projects so that they could be completed within the current budget cycle.
Zakarpattia and Zhytomyr regions, NGO Charitable Foundation Brave
Unlike earlier formalistic strategies, current strategies in most of the communities monitored by the team in Zhytomyr and Zakarpattia regions are, according to their observations, substantive and developed with the involvement of businesses, councillors, municipal employees and, in some cases, members of the public. However, public participation itself remains weak: residents take part in the initial meetings and voice their wishes, but do not return to the working groups and later complain at the final presentation that their views were not taken into account.
A positive trend is that communities are beginning to define their own areas of specialisation rather than trying to develop everything at once – healthcare, education, roads and so on. Examples include Zviahel in Zhytomyr region, which focuses on supporting military veterans, and Khust, which has identified itself as a city of industry and science. At the same time, larger cities such as Uzhhorod remain “cities that try to cover everything”.
However, communities still find it difficult to understand the purpose of the public investment reform. According to their representatives, project preparation now takes considerably longer – one or two months longer than before. Specialists responsible for public investment projects are heavily overloaded and, in most cases, cannot combine this work with other responsibilities. There are also complaints that the DREAM system rejects applications over minor errors in titles, requiring them to be resubmitted three months later.
Smaller communities, such as Korosten, often have no such specialists at all. In Khust, when the head of the economics department fell ill, public investment projects were prepared by the first deputy mayor, who temporarily put aside his other responsibilities.
According to Vitalii Selik, co-founder of Brave, one of the problems is the active involvement of councillors in investment councils. The system of checks and balances loses its purpose when the decisions of investment councils are then formally approved by a session of the same councillors. The situation is even more acute in small communities, where the same people prepare projects, sit on investment councils and later implement the projects.
As an example of “manual management”, the team cited a social centre project in Khust – the restoration of a 19th-century building for lease to the Ministry of Internal Affairs for a specialised centre. The project is personally supervised by the head of the regional administration, who was born in Khust and visits the site every weekend. Construction projects should, of course, be overseen by relevant professionals rather than regional officials.
The Public Investment Watchdog project is implemented by the Centre for Economic Strategy, the Institute for Economic Research and Policy Consulting (IER), and the NGO Technologies of Progress with financial support from the European Union. It includes a sub-grant component, “Public Investment Watchdog”, under which ten civil society organisations monitor public investment projects. The contents of this publication do not necessarily reflect the views of the European Union.