Think tanks’ appeal regarding changes to Ukraine’s military reservation rules

To the President of Ukraine

To the Prime Minister of Ukraine

To the Minister of Economy and Environment of Ukraine

To the Minister of Finance of Ukraine

To the Chair of the Verkhovna Rada Committee on Economic Development

To the Head of the Office of the President of Ukraine

To the National Agency on Corruption Prevention

 

Regarding the draft amendments to the rules for reserving employees liable for military service

The undersigned economic policy think tanks wish to draw your attention to the following.

Experts from the think tanks have analysed the revised draft resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine, prepared by the Ministry of Economy and Environment, entitled “Certain Issues Concerning the Organisation of the Reservation of Persons Liable for Military Service During Mobilisation and Wartime” (hereinafter, the Draft Resolution). It proposes establishing a Coordination Centre for the Organisation of the Reservation of Persons Liable for Military Service (hereinafter, the Coordination Centre), reducing the maximum reservation quotas and changing the procedure for designating enterprises as critically important.

We share the objective stated by the Draft Resolution’s authors: to prevent unlawful employment schemes designed to obtain reservations and the manipulation of the number of employees liable for military service. At the same time, such changes must be based on an analysis of their economic consequences, an assessment of staffing needs across government bodies and critically important enterprises, and the development of balanced solutions that address both defence and economic needs during wartime.

The approaches proposed by the Government pose serious risks to the fulfilment of defence contracts, the operation of energy and utility infrastructure, and the continuity of services provided by enterprises that are critical to the public. They also increase corruption risks and uncertainty, encourage the informalisation of the economy and undermine business activity.

The Coordination Centre as an additional layer: delays, duplication and a lack of transparency

The Coordination Centre, comprising 17 members and co-chaired by deputy ministers of economy and defence, would be involved in determining critical-importance status, approving reservation quotas above 50%, endorsing criteria and issuing recommendations on the revocation of status.

Risks

Delays. Even under the revised time limits, the procedure for granting critical-importance status could take up to 17 working days, compared with the current 10. No consequences are specified for failure to issue recommendations within the prescribed period, and there is no provision for a “silence is consent” rule. No time limits are set for increasing reservation quotas above 50%, approving criteria or revoking critical-importance status.

Duplication and administrative barriers. The Ministry of Digital Transformation did not support the establishment of the Centre, arguing that the additional layer lacks adequate justification, duplicates the functions of government bodies, extends processing times, creates administrative barriers and complicates the process of obtaining critical-importance status. It proposed achieving the objective by improving the existing mechanism instead.

An unclear legal status. The Centre is established as a temporary advisory body, yet its recommendations would determine the outcomes of administrative procedures: quotas above 50% would be established “on the basis of” its recommendations, while the criteria would require its approval. The Ministry of Justice noted that these powers are administrative in nature and are not appropriate for an advisory body. The Ministry of Energy also pointed to inconsistencies with the Model Regulations on Advisory Bodies, approved by Cabinet Resolution No. 599. No term of operation is specified for the temporary body.

Composition and working procedures. The Centre would comprise representatives of government bodies and law enforcement agencies, with no business representatives included. Recommendations would be adopted by a simple majority of those present, with a quorum of more than half the members. This means that, in theory, just five votes out of 17 could suffice. Whether an enterprise may participate in the proceedings concerning its case would be left to the Centre’s discretion. The publication of minutes and decisions is not provided for.

Revocation of critical-importance status without procedural safeguards

New paragraph 18 of the Criteria provides that the Coordination Centre’s recommendations “constitute grounds” for revoking an enterprise’s critical-importance status. The Centre’s regulations also allow it to issue such recommendations, including where grounds are identified by law enforcement agencies.

The Draft Resolution does not define the grounds for revocation, the procedure for notifying an enterprise, its right to submit explanations, decision-making deadlines, requirements for reasoned decisions or an appeal mechanism. In its opinion dated 12 October 2026, the National Agency on Corruption Prevention (NACP) noted that the absence of deadlines and criteria creates conditions conducive to non-transparent procedures and abuse. The proposal to establish an exhaustive list of grounds was rejected by the Draft Resolution’s authors, who argued that the grounds could vary. This creates an asymmetry: status is granted “taking into account” recommendations, but may be revoked on the basis of a recommendation. Under the general logic of the Procedure, loss of status removes the grounds for employees’ deferments from mobilisation. For an enterprise, this could cause a sudden operational disruption, particularly when fulfilling defence contracts or carrying out repairs at energy facilities.

A rushed review of critical-importance criteria across almost all sectors

Under paragraph 4 of the Draft Resolution, central executive authorities and regional administrations would be required to review their critical-importance criteria and obtain the Coordination Centre’s approval by 20 October 2026. The review would cover, among other sectors, the fuel and energy sector, housing and utilities, the defence industry, healthcare, communications, emergency and rescue services, food security, retail, banking, construction, transport and logistics.

In effect, a substantial part of the economy would be subject to reassessment only a few months after the previous review. This would have to be completed within a matter of days, without public discussion of the revised criteria. The Draft Resolution does not define either “verifiable indicators” or the salary threshold. As a result, the criteria could be interpreted arbitrarily. Nor does it clarify whether tax debts that are being contested or are subject to an approved payment instalment plan should be taken into account. For small and medium-sized businesses in retail, construction and logistics, this creates a risk of losing critical-importance status not because their role in the economy has changed, but because the procedure is uncertain.

A closed decision-making process, no impact assessment and inconsistencies in the supporting documents

The explanatory note to the Draft Resolution states that public consultations are unnecessary. No quantitative assessment has been provided of the potential impact on enterprises, employees, production, the energy system, budget revenues or foreign-exchange earnings. The note claims that the Draft Resolution poses no corruption risks, whereas the NACP’s opinion of 12 October 2026 identifies corruption-generating factors and states that the Draft Resolution requires further revision. The authors have only partially incorporated the recommendations: neither an exhaustive list of grounds for refusal nor procedures for the Coordination Centre to consider cases have been established.

The comments of the Ministry of Energy, the Ministry of Justice and the Ministry of Digital Transformation have not been taken into account. The only justification provided by the Draft Resolution’s authors in the consultation record is that its provisions comply with a decision of the Staff of the Supreme Commander-in-Chief.

Furthermore, the Draft Resolution was not submitted for public discussion, and no consultations were held with leading business associations or non-governmental organisations.

In the assessment of the think tanks, the Draft Resolution in its current form does not achieve its stated objective and poses significant risks to businesses, national defence and Ukraine’s economic resilience.

Key concerns

  • The proposed instruments do not match the stated objective. Instead of targeted inspections of enterprises suspected of abuse, the Draft Resolution introduces across-the-board quota reductions and a reassessment of critical-importance status in almost every sector.
  • A new decision-making layer is being introduced without clear deadlines, criteria, transparency, the right to be heard or an appeal mechanism. The powers of an advisory body would, in practice, become administrative powers. This creates substantial corruption risks.
  • The Centre’s recommendations would constitute grounds for revoking critical-importance status without procedural safeguards, while no transitional provisions are provided for statuses and reservations already granted.
  • Restrictions are being introduced in sectors that are particularly vulnerable and at a particularly unfavourable time, without a quantitative assessment of their consequences or consultations with stakeholders.
  • Substantive comments from the Ministry of Energy, the Ministry of Justice, the Ministry of Digital Transformation and, in part, the NACP have not received adequate responses.

Our recommendations

We call on the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine to take urgent steps to prevent the adverse consequences of the proposed changes and to revise the Draft Resolution in light of the concerns raised by think tanks, relevant ministries and the business community. We propose implementing a package of measures in two stages.

1. Urgent measures – by 20 October 2026

  • Introduce a moratorium on reviewing critical-importance criteria and revoking the status of critically important enterprises until the regulatory framework has been revised.
  • Establish a 90-day transition period during which existing reservations remain valid, allowing enterprises to adapt to the new rules without jeopardising operational continuity, the fulfilment of defence contracts or the operation of critical infrastructure.

2. Revision of the regulatory framework – within 30 days

  • Limit the Coordination Centre’s remit to a purely advisory role in developing reservation policy, with the authority to submit recommendations to the Cabinet of Ministers on reservation-related matters.
  • Establish an exhaustive list of grounds for revoking an enterprise’s critical-importance status and guarantee the enterprise’s right to prior notification, to submit explanations, to receive a reasoned decision and to appeal that decision.
  • Establish clear, measurable critical-importance criteria, including definitions of “verifiable indicators” and the salary threshold, and clarify how tax debts that are being contested or are subject to an approved payment instalment plan should be treated.
  • Conduct a mandatory assessment of the economic, fiscal and staffing implications of the proposed changes, including their impact on defence capabilities, critical infrastructure, employment and budget revenues.

To develop balanced solutions promptly, we propose establishing a working group comprising the Ministry of Economy and Environment of Ukraine, the Ministry of Defence of Ukraine, the think tanks signing this statement and leading business associations. We believe that the existing Interagency Working Group on Small and Micro Businesses at the Ministry of Economy could serve as a ready-made platform for this work, with its membership expanded, if necessary, to include the relevant representatives.

The think tanks are ready to contribute to this work and provide expert support. We are convinced that cooperation between the government, businesses and independent experts will make it possible to address abuses in the reservation system, meet defence needs and preserve Ukraine’s economic resilience.

Yours sincerely,

The undersigned think tanks:

Centre for Social and Economic Research – CASE Ukraine

Institute for Economic Research and Policy Consulting

Institute of Social and Economic Transformation

Centre for Economic Strategy

Ukrainian Institute of Legal Policy

ANTS National Interests Advocacy Network

Growford Institute

Institute for Tax Reforms

Association of Tax Advisers

Institute of Economic Leadership

Advanter Group Analytical Centre

Office of the Chief Economist of the Coalition of Business Communities for the Modernisation of Ukraine

Analytical Group of the Economic Expert Platform

Institute of Finance and Law

“Technology of Progress” Analytical Centre

Kyiv Foresight Foundation

Previous news item

42% of community projects are in education. Is Poltava region investing in the right priorities?

Next news item

Business Activity Recovery Index falls to its lowest level since early 2023 – IER survey