-
Product type:
Analytical Document -
Authors:
-
Date:
06 March 2009 -
With financial support from:
The role of trade policy in reducing Ukraine’s current account deficit – lessons from abroad
Deficit was comfortably financed by capital inflows, but since then net capital inflows decreased dramatically and the size and the financing of the current account deficit became an urgent problem for the country. Initially, Ukraine has focused, in accordance with the IMF stand-by agreement, on macroeconomic policies and especially on the flexibilisation of the exchange rate to reduce its current account deficit. However, by the end of 2008 protectionist sentiments intensified in the country. Disregarding the constraints set in the Memorandum with the IMF, Ukraine’s Parliament passed several laws envisaging various trade policy measures aimed at coping with the crisis. The most important one is a law which foresees the temporary introduction of additional import charges for all products excluding “critical” imports. In addition, several other laws have been proposed envisaging sector-specific support based on a range of measures including higher import barriers.
A review of other countries’ crisis responses in terms of trade policy measures demonstrates that countries vary considerably in their trade policy measures adopted. The most common measure used to promote exports is trade finance. This measure is in compliance with WTO regulations. Countries also liberalise their trade regimes as a crisis response by eliminating export barriers and relaxing import restrictions for certain products. The most common measure to restrict imports is the increase in import tariffs. Apart from most likely causing trade disputes with affected trade partners, increasing selectively import tariffs also opens an opportunity for lobby groups to pursue their interests, which is unlikely to result in an adequate policy response to the problems posed by the current crisis.
Considering the constraints posed by Ukraine’s trade structure and its commitments with regard to IMF and WTO, we come to the following conclusions and recommendations:
- In the case of Ukraine, macroeconomic policies are better suited to address its balance of payments problems. The adoption of protectionist measures should be regarded as an inadequate policy response to combat the economic crisis. In particular, we recommend abolishing a recently introduced temporary import surcharge on ”non-critical” imports because it is not conducive to a good relationship with the IMF, opens the way for longterm protection of specific industries, might provoke retaliation from trading partners, and could result in a loss of international trade competitiveness in the long-term.
- To promote exports, Ukraine should promote export finance and insurance through direct government support and through support from multilateral organisations.
- We recommended to eliminate (temporarily) export taxes on edible oil seeds or to reduce them immediately to 10% as already committed to during Ukraine’s WTO accession.
IER Project
German Economic Team in Ukraine (GET)The project aims to develop economic policy recommendations for Ukraine based on rigorous analysis, contemporary economic theory and international best practices to support well-informed policy decisions and help identify priorities for economic development